Elizabeth O'Reilly

Blessed to be doing what I love and loving it!

Coldwell Banker
864 Highway 35, Middletown, NJ 07748


Tel: 732-842-3200
Cell: 732-456-4476

Markets Served: Rumson, NJ;Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey;Oceanport, New Jersey;Middletown, New Jersey;Monmouth Beach, New Jersey;

What do Clients Say?

"Very helpful. Answered any questions I had and was always available. Has lots of knowledge of real estate. I would recommend Elizabeth O'Reilly to anyone looking to buy or sell their house. A pleasure to work with."

Joe I

Elizabeth O’Reilly is not only an absolute gem of a realtor she is an amazing person as well. Coming from a first time homebuyer with not the most ideal situation Beth did not push me aside, she went above and beyond to get me my first home. Not only that, after the offer was accepted she was with me the entire two months before closing, she went through everything I needed to know and answered any questions, and trust me there were A LOT. I will always recommend Beth to my friends and family.

Jackie K.

This was me and my husband's first time going through the home buying experience, and Beth was a dream to work with from beginning to end!! Beth is super knowledgeable on the Monmouth County, NJ area we were looking at. She was very patient with us and stayed focused on what we wanted, we never felt rushed or pressured to look at anything outside of our wants or budget. We started our search during the height of quarantine, and even during these crazy times she always went above and beyond to meet with us on short notice, quickly respond to questions, and ultimately push for us and advise us during the bidding/closing process. We trusted her 100% and truly felt like she had our backs throughout the entire process! She is a true professional, but also such a calming presence and great company to be around. We feel so lucky to have worked with Beth on finding our perfect starter home, and we CANNOT recommend her enough!!

Jennifer S.

It has been more than a pleasure to work with Beth! She makes herself readily available when convenient for you. Always goes above and beyond to make sure all questions are answered accurately. She is ALWAYS quick to respond. She is highly recommended for making what is known as a stressful experience so much easier and more pleasant.

Erin D.

A perfect experience in every way. Elizabeth was the best! From the first phone call through to the ultimate closing of our new property, Beth was there every step of the way to assist and guide us through the process.

Buyers - Avon By The Sea

About Elizabeth

Elizabeth (Beth) O’Reilly is a seasoned local professional with 20+ years in real estate. A high-touch REALTOR known for her extensive market knowledge and her unmatched devotion to clients, her success is based almost exclusively on positive referrals. She is dedicated to finding the perfect match for her clients; whether a classic beach house or new construction, she understands her clients’ needs and consistently makes their experience efficient and enjoyable. Beth’s ultimate joy comes from putting a SOLD sign on a lawn or passing keys over to ecstatic new homeowners!

In addition to her career in residential real estate, Beth has extensive knowledge within the field of new construction. She worked alongside Ryan Homes, a leader in the industry, where her exceptional sales and marketing skills were widely recognized. This experience strengthened her innate ability to efficiently assess the clients’ needs to achieve their goals.

“ Within minutes of meeting us, she read our personality, likes and dislikes, and was able to quickly turn around a number of listings that met our exact criteria. It’s like she knew what we were looking for before we even knew what we wanted.” Tara B. from Monmouth Beach

A Jersey girl, she is deeply connected to her community and is committed to giving back to those who serve. Beth frequently assists first responders with their real estate needs and is a proud supporter of the NJ State Firefighters' Mutual Benevolent Association.  As a cancer survivor, she voluntarily assists newly-diagnosed individuals with available resources in the areas of nutrition, wellness and emotional support.

Beth has lived in NJ towns stretching from Atlantic Highlands to Margate. Her exceptional knowledge of these communities affords newcomers with an insiders’ perspective to the area.

Currently she resides in Monmouth County. When she isn’t working, she loves cooking, spending time at the beach and hiking with her dog, Kiya.